1. Chat

Would You Give up Your Seat for a Child?

Ask a Question

Saw this online this morning:

A commuter has sparked a fierce debate after refusing to give up her Tube seat to a six-year-old child following a long day on her feet.

The mum called her rude, but the woman argued healthy kids are fine to stand. Was she in the wrong, or totally within her rights?

hspexy
5 days ago
Comments+20 points
jms19

I mean when I was growing up it was always the other way around, children give up their seats for adults. At six years old surely the child could have sat on their mothers lap. Where has this even become a thing that adults give up seats to children? Now I can sort of see the argument for children not having to give up their seats for adults but I cannot see any logical explanation for a grown woman to give her seat up to a six year old child.

Like
hspexy

jms19 I agree. In the far east, it’s always the child that is expected to give up the seat for their elders, and obviously the older, the more they’d need the seat. But I know if it’s a busy train, some people may give up the seat to small children so they’re not squashed to trampled on by big adults, but aside from that rationale, I don’t know why a child is unable to stand (particularly as a lot of kids are far happier freely moving around anyway, as being seated is boring to them). There’s definitely a spoilt generation

Like
kitty88uk

jms19 yeah same here on bus if see elderly people give them your seat never the other way around. Pfft the mum was rude herself her kid could have sat on her lap as you said! Fml 🤦🏻‍♀️ some people are just annoying

Like
MelissaLee1

I saw an Octogenerian standing ne balancing on a bus with a frame while all the front seats were filled with people under 30.Three of whom were young children and the others young men and women of about 30-40. I always stood as a child or sat on a family members lap.I am 63 and always give my seat to someone needier .Suffice it to say that is not a child or anyone under 30 unless seriously handicapped. I get that it is easier to just pile all your children on the seats to keep em huddled but when I have to ask for my 87 year old mum to sit down its just wrong. Image

Like
hspexy

MelissaLee1 I agree. It’s common courtesy to offer it to those in need, and the older generation often need it more. I mean, I know that sometimes parents may want a seat for their child to stop them running amok, but they don’t actually need it if their legs are perfectly fine. I guess it’s also down to how busy it is, as parents may worry about their kids getting trampled on if the train is packed, but if there’s standing space, a 6 year old can stand (in London, unfortunately it’s become common for people to ignore those in need)

Like
TheChimp

When I was growing up, I always offered to give up my seat for someone a lot older. They called it manners back then.

No, I would never have given up my seat to a 6 year old who would either be on their tablet or screaming the place down.

Like
hspexy

TheChimp how the new generations have been spoiled! If it had been the other way round, I wouldn’t expect a kid to give up their seat to an able bodied person (fatigue is not a condition that qualifies) but I’d want them to at least be considerate of others - so rather than the parent arguing, it was better to just explain to their child why they won’t always get a seat/get what they want (how life is so hard sometimes)

Like
TheChimp

hspexy Agreed.

Parenting seems to have gone out the window. Fancy sending a 5 year old to school who isn't even potty trained.

And as for teachers, they're too scared to hurt the kid's feelings.

And it's only going to get worse by the looks of it.

Like
hspexy

TheChimp I don’t believe they are teachers anymore - just daycare attendants who manage overgrown babies (I’m sure the grading system in academy will be going soon enough, replaced with just words of encouragement)

Like
Leannexxx

I would always give my sit up for an older person I didn't once as she was a nasty old woman she was rude to everyone on the bus

Like
hspexy

Leannexxx ah yes, the entitled types - there always are a few

Like
Leannexxx

hspexy entitled isn't the word I would use 😂

Like
eyeballkerry

I believe each situation is different. In the past I have given up my seat to people who look less able than me but when I am the train recently with crutches only one gentleman out of four train journeys offered me his seat. I think if you travel by public transport you have to expect you may not get a seat so be prepared to stand or not travel.

Like
AlysonC

We were brought up to offer our seats to an older person or a person who may have a frailty, and I expected the same from my own children.

However, what I found interesting was being offered a seat when I was clearly pregnant, but not being offered a seat when I had a young baby in my arms on a packed train. There was no room for the buggy unless folded, and we travelled for a few hours leaning precariously against some seats.

Like
Pjran

The mother and child had just boarded the tube then asked the woman. The tube was packed! Maybe the mother was wrong to take a small child during rush hour BUT how could that child hold on?

Like
PhilipMarc

Sorry, nope. If I'm tired I'm not getting up, the only exception would be old people or someone disabled, that I'd be willing to do.

Like
One of the UK's largest deal hunting communities

Join for free to get genuine deals, money saving advice and help from our friendly community

Tom Church
Co-Founder &
Chief Bargain Hunter
Tom Church, Co-Founder