1. Chat

The New John Lewis Christmas Advert, What Do You Think?

In the News

https://www.johnlewis.com/content/christmas-advert

Watch The New John Lewis Christmas Advert and give your opinion, sadly I don't think they are as good as they used to be, I used to look forward to their ad every year, as it was always imaginative, but I think those days are gone!

JoTarpley
6 days ago
Comments+20 points
jillylovesyou

I loved it remembered that wheelie dog played with it a lot. I thought the advert had a good underlying meaning that Christmas is about experiences and memories more than money can buy.

Like
JoTarpley

jillylovesyou Memories are so important in your life, good ones preferably, they are much more important than material possessions, I'll watch it again and be more open minded I think!

Like
hspexy

Well made, but easy to forget. Fun, but not remarkable. John Lewis definitely wanted to portray ‘British’ in the ad, but ensured they were box ticking also (just sooo predictable). It doesn’t tug at my heart strings, nor does it make John Lewis stand out or make me want to shop there for Christmas, so it’s a no for me

Like
JoTarpley

hspexy John Lewis used to make some really lovely Christmas Adverts, there were so many, but my absolute favourite has to be Keane’s Somewhere Only We Know, do you remember that, the song was everywhere at the time, it was so lovely, then there was Tom Odell's Real Love I remember, adverts used to come out at Christmas but everybody used to wait for John Lewis's, I'm afraid this one left me a bit cold!

Like
hspexy

JoTarpley yes, I remember them. They were far more memorable and had warmth. I didn’t feel anything for this one - cant speak for everyone, but i dont believe it will be the best ad this Christmas

Like
kitty88uk

Haven’t seen it yet, just saw the Aldi one of Kevin the carrot 🥕 wit a pup 🐶 and then saw the Sainsbury’s one about giants. Nothing special and I’m sure they did one the same last year? Can’t remember as I don’t pay that much attention lol

Like
JoTarpley

kitty88uk Well the advert is here on this posting, 🤔 perhaps you could find a couple of minutes to watch it and then say what you think??

Like
kitty88uk

JoTarpley I meant Sainsburys one nothing new lol yeah seen John Lewis it’s sort of heartwarming and the wooden toy is nostalgic

Like
jms19

I saw this yesterday and to be honest it wasn’t bad but it was very very generic. There seems to be so many adverts like this every Christmas that it didn’t really stand out to me. I also kind of thought the message was a bit bad as it was telling people to buy gifts, when sometimes that might not be possible. I get that obviously John Lewis want this and wouldn’t encourage people to just buy what they can afford.

The advert was too long as well at 3 minutes, I’m sure we will all be sick of this long before Christmas day.

Like
JoTarpley

jms19 I thought it was too long as well, you want something memorable, that sticks in your mind, I'm afraid this sticks in my mind for all the wrong reasons!

Like
eyeballkerry

So wrong in so many ways in my opinion for what’s it worth. Poor grandmother, on her own it seems, has got her home beautifully ready for her family to visit. But the brat children arrive with their parents who have no control over them. The grandchildren rush into the home, totally ignore grandma, they jump on her furniture, they shake the cards they are given expecting money. Someone quoted after seeing the advert that if they were grandma they would tell the ungrateful grandchildren they had sponsored a donkey in their names. I think John Lewis has definitely got it wrong. I understand what they trying to do but messed up with the children’s behaviour.

Like
One of the UK's largest deal hunting communities

Join for free to get genuine deals, money saving advice and help from our friendly community

Tom Church
Co-Founder &
Chief Bargain Hunter
Tom Church, Co-Founder