1. Home
  2. Chat
  3. Best Ketchup - Blind Taste Test

Best Ketchup - Blind Taste Test

Ask a Question

Shopping for the tastiest tomato ketchup is a nightmare in our house.

We’ve tried Heinz, Hellmann’s and own brands from Sainsbugs, Waitrose, M&S and Asda.

Which brand of tomato ketchup wins in your household?

HappyTravels
24 days ago
What do you think of this?
cocolgooh
cocolgooh24 days ago

I usually get Crucials. They do a huge range of sauces and I’m yet to find any I don’t like. I quite like Daddies ketchup too though.

Like
Reply
1
neo1
neo124 days ago

I dont it have that much to be fair but im about half way through Aldi's own brand one atm. I wont be getting it again, very thin and not much taste

Like
Reply
1
HappyTravels
HappyTravels
Original Poster
24 days ago

neo1 good to know, thanks. Aldi’s own was one the list to try but I’ll just dodge it now.

Like
Reply
1
Leannexxx
Leannexxx24 days ago

I wouldn't know i don't buy ketchup we are all brown sauce people lol

Like
Reply
1
HappyTravels
HappyTravels
Original Poster
24 days ago

Leannexxx oh I’m partial to a good brown sauce too but no-one else is 😟

Like
Reply
2
seasider71
seasider7124 days ago

We go through loads of ketchup and it has to be Heinz. It's the one that everyone likes. If it was up to me I'd be happy with the one from Lidl.

Like
Reply
1
Nadiaparveen
Nadiaparveen24 days ago

Fam loves Aldi's ketchup

Like
Reply
1
HappyTravels
HappyTravels
Original Poster
24 days ago

Nadiaparveen ah, interesting. Just reading the comments and had removed it from the list still to try due to neo1 Might just let the kids figure it out amongst themselves. As soon as the sauce is decanted onto the plate, I’m sure they’ve really no idea which brand is which! 🤣🤦‍♀️

Like
Reply
3
Nadiaparveen
Nadiaparveen24 days ago

HappyTravels must be fun doing this experiment 😃

Like
Reply
1
HappyTravels
HappyTravels
Original Poster
24 days ago

Nadiaparveen that’s what lockdown has done to our family 😬🤦‍♀️🤣🤣

Like
Reply
3
Nadiaparveen
Nadiaparveen24 days ago

HappyTravels I think it's a fab idea 😍

Like
Reply
lynneh
lynneh24 days ago

Bramwells personally. But have also found that making diff dishes with flavours the tomato ketchup has been put on the back burner.

Like
Reply
1
ch7leach
ch7leach24 days ago

Mrs only likes the heinz one. I very rarely have it and don't tend to care so much

Like
Reply
1
Bossclaz
Bossclaz24 days ago

I love m&s own brand one it's so much nicer than heinz with a more tomato taste

Like
Reply
1
hspexy
hspexy24 days ago

We do have Heinz, but we do get the supermarket own brands too, as I tend to mix chilli with everything anyway

Like
Reply
gerrykelly25
gerrykelly2524 days ago

Very brand loyal in our house! It has to be Heinz and HP. We get the no added sugar or salt version of the ketchup.

Like
Reply
1
MrsCraig
MrsCraig24 days ago

I just buy the Lidl own one. My husband and son will eat pretty much anything. Just put it in front of them and it's gone! I like the Lidl and Aldi own. Morrisons own one is good, as is their value one. Tesco value one is good too. I haven't bought Heinz in years.

In my house it is a case of you eat what is in front of you.

Like
Reply
1
TheChimp
TheChimp23 days ago

Hellman's one is horrid imo.

I'm sure that they put honey in it 🤮

Used it one time and it went straight in the bin.

Like
Reply
1
PinkElephant26
PinkElephant2623 days ago

I dont like tomato ketchup but my partner & kids do and i buy the aldi ketchup but they all say heinz is the best.

Like
Reply
1
BORDERJOE
BORDERJOE23 days ago

we will generally use own-brands but with ketchup tend to stick with Heinz ... same for salad cream

Like
Reply
1
lornaae
lornaae23 days ago

Usually buy either Heinz if it’s on offer or just the Asda own brand. I like that Heinz offer a reduced salt version.

Like
Reply
1
RichardDoolin
RichardDoolin23 days ago

I really liked the red and green tomato ketchup. It's a shame that Hellman's no longer make it. 🙄

Like
Reply
tumblespots
tumblespots23 days ago

We tend to have Heinz tomato sauce as one of us is fussy (ha, ha) but also love the HP honey BBQ sauce which is very tasty. Image

Like
Reply
Pppathome
Pppathome22 days ago

Heinz

Like
Reply
One of the UK's largest deal hunting communities

Join for free to get genuine deals, money saving advice and help from our friendly community

Kelsey, Tom
& Deepak
Founders
Founders of Latest Deals
We use cookies (e.g. personalisation, analytics, social media). Find out more.