1. Chat

Heavier Weight of Electric Vehicles Could Cause Car Parks to Collapse

In the News

Anyone that reads my posts will know i am not a fan of EVs

They are expensive, not practical yet for long distances with few and high costs at charging stations

Never mind the extra taxes being brought in and battery disposal issue

Now engineers are warning of the danger of multi story carparks collapsing due to the extra weight of EVs

Most were built well before electric vehicles were thought of, and only designed to take the weight of a normal car

Not only this , what about car ferries, have they factored in the extra weight also for the cost of journeys ??

I can see this also being a problem in the future

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/04/08/old-car-parks-could-collapse-under-weight-electric-cars/#:~:text=Car%20parks%20could%20collapse%20under%20the%20weight%20of%20electric%20cars&text=Multi%2Dstorey%20car%20parks%20across,ageing%20infrastructure%2C%20experts%20have%20warned.

telmel
a year ago
What do you think of this?+20 points
Advertisement
BonzoBanana

It's not really a problem with EV's as such but the ridiculous move to large SUVs. Many electric vehicles are light and small but we are ending up with electric SUVs that do more damage to roads, block emergency vehicles (SUV's in general) and of course cost more to import and do more damage to our economy. If you are trying to protect the environment, keep your existing vehicle and use it less, instead walk or use a bike or ebike.

It would be so easy for the government to tax such vehicles more excessively and have a tax system for vehicles that starts off at a high rate when new but reduces year by year thereby motivating people to keep their car longer and maybe for large heavy electric SUV's they would not have that reduction in yearly licensing. It makes sense now that we have only a small amount of vehicle manufacturing left to start thinking about policies that will help our economy and the environment at the same time. We need to move to vehicles that only hold one or two people as that is the most common amount of people in car vehicles in use but instead we have single people going around in huge cars that can take up to 7 people. Licensing/tax that reflects the weight of the vehicle and the number of seats should be a priority. You should pay a huge premium for such vehicles.

On a side note I think cars should have a included 7 year warranty. This would penalise unreliable cars which rely on constant repair income like many of the German brands. Those brands would end up at extremely uncompetitive prices and probably leave the UK market or only import more reliable cars which are typically simpler models. Having a long warranty would motivate people to keep their car longer perhaps until the warranty finishes.

On so many levels heavy electric SUVs are bad for our economy.

Like
Reply1
telmel

BonzoBanana I totally agree B

Also about the larger cars, people are lucky the government doesn't introduce a supplement car tax on the number of seats, similar to the hated bedroom tax , i am sure they would if they thought they could get away with it

Like
Reply
Jerseydrew

Oh my gosh. Makes sense as I'm guessing they are heavier and carparks were built when cars where lighter. Most of the car parks where I am where built in like the the 60's and spaces were smaller because cars were smaller

Like
Reply1
telmel

Jerseydrew This is where the problem lies J, the older car parks were only built to support lighter and shorter vehicles , so combine this with the deteriorating and ageing concrete and this is a disaster waiting to happen , similar to the concrete scandal for school roofs

PS Big coincidence i am just watching a documentary on BBC 2 about a collapse of a block of apartments in Miami in 2021 , Champagne Towers , a slightly different situation but a collapse all the same possibly caused by a heavy roof pool that was also leaking into the structure amongst other faults

Like
Reply
BonzoBanana

Strangely enough there is a news story today about a car park collapsing and killing people in New York I think. It may not be related to EVs or maybe it is I guess we will find out the cause later.

Our politicians are pretty clueless, it will probably take 2 or 3 collapsed high rise car parks before they do anything and then what they do probably will be the wrong thing to do. I don't see why a simple ban on heavy vehicles shouldn't be done on many car parks and roads with a simple weight limit especially older high rise car parks and older roads with poor surfaces.

Like
Reply
telmel

BonzoBanana I think this my be necessary B in light of what is happening in the US , as you say it takes a while for the message to get through to our politicians , a few disasters and they may get it eventually

Like
Reply
One of the UK's largest deal hunting communities

Join for free to get genuine deals, money saving advice and help from our friendly community

Tom Church
Co-Founder &
Chief Bargain Hunter
Tom Church, Co-Founder
We value your privacy

We use cookies to help give you the best experience on our website with improved customisation, analytics & advertising (inc. personalisation). You can read our full cookie policy. Please either , or .