1. Chat

Should Young Drivers Pay More for Car Insurance?

Ask a Question

Should young drivers have to pay more for car insurance?

Insurance costs for 17-24 year olds have skyrocketed to £3,000. But is it fair given their higher risk?

Source: www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-67991154

SamGoodship
2 weeks ago
What do you think of this?+20 points
Advertisement
MrsCraig

I don't think that it is fair for them to be paying £3000 but they should be paying a little more as they are a higher risk. I paid a higher premium when I first passed and it dropped down as I got older. It is the same for every driver but I do think £3000 is excessive.

Like
Reply1
jms19

It doesn’t seem fair but then insurance in general doesn’t seem fair to me. If you drive for 50 years and never claim imagine the money you have spent for basically nothing.

Like
Reply1
Pfs

Cheaper if you don't have insurance as the penalty of getting caught isn't as much

Like
Reply
suevernon1968

Pfs it is if you cause an accident and kill someone. They also have the power to seize your car and won’t release it to you until you prove you have insurance- they also charge you storage per day. You then get a conviction on your license increasing your insurance. Can you tell i worked in insurance for a while?

Like
Reply1
Pjran

Insurance has rocketed for everyone but it’s unjust for those who have just passed their test regardless of age.

Like
Reply
eyeballkerry

It always has been higher and for a young person the insurance is usually more than the cost of their first car. I remember when my son started driving, it nearly emptied his bank account.

Like
Reply
janphoenix51

Young people have the famous black box fitted for cheaper Insurance...

Only yesterday as I walked back to work with my service user I saw a sticker..

Black Box fitted....Believe me,

I'm as peed off as you mate!!!

Similar wording to PEED OFF if you get my meaning!

Like
Reply
NanaP

Think it’s a bit high for young drivers and out of some just can’t afford it, think they should pay a bit and if they have a claim which is there fault there premiums should them be a lot higher so there penalised for bad driving

Like
Reply
kraton007

They should pay more for insurance, my street is supposed to be access only, but the younger drivers do race down it as a short cut + they are involved in the most accidents.

Like
Reply
BonzoBanana

Close to a million cars on the road now without insurance and tax etc. Such is the ridiculous light punishment for people who don't legally drive. So a lot of young drivers are probably paying zero pounds which is very affordable.

Like
Reply
jdible

No it's not fair they need to pay a bit more than others but not being robbed

Like
Reply
kimcress

My son is 19, hasn’t learnt to drive yet as insurance is sky high. I remember when I learnt at 21, was out as second driver on a golf gti and we never paid more than £400!

A slightly higher premium would be ok but in excess of £3k is just ludicrous.

Like
Reply
suevernon1968

Figures are based on information from actuaries who obviously get all the information of what groups (ages, postcode, car, any convictions etc) and apparently work out a logarithm which is the ‘base’ that insurance companies use. Its always best to shop around. I have to say I have seen many really old people with shocking driving habits too though

Like
Reply
One of the UK's largest deal hunting communities

Join for free to get genuine deals, money saving advice and help from our friendly community

Tom Church
Co-Founder &
Chief Bargain Hunter
Tom Church, Co-Founder
We value your privacy

We use cookies to help give you the best experience on our website with improved customisation, analytics & advertising (inc. personalisation). You can read our full cookie policy. Please either , or .